Dirt and Stars
John's investigation uncovers new details about Sheriff Kane and Noah while bringing him closer to discovering who killed Hal Jordan. Meanwhile, John Stewart confronts the issues surrounding his upbringing and finally begins to make peace with his past. As he takes an important step forward in his personal journey, John embraces his future as a Lantern.
Warning: Spoilers Below
Hal’s Release
The episode opens in the aftermath of Rushville's destruction in 2016. Sheriff Kane asks Hal, “Was it worth it?” He can't help but laugh because those are the exact words he once used when confronting John. It's a fitting callback that connects their stories. The episode then jumps forward to 2026, when Hal is released from prison. Kane is waiting to pick him up, and with her marriage now over, the two begin a relationship. Hal settles in Rushville, hoping to make amends for what happened a decade earlier.
Photograph by John Johnson/HBO Max
Unfortunately, being responsible for the disaster, or at least being blamed for it by the townspeople, makes it difficult for Hal to get the fresh start he desires. Even Sheriff Kane's public declaration of love for him at a restaurant does little to assuage the community's anger. The hostility eventually follows Hal home when someone sets his house on fire one night. He manages to escape with some unexpected help, or perhaps not so unexpected if you've been paying attention to the clues.
Manhunter
At the hospital, Noah reveals to Hal that he is a Manhunter, just like his grandmother, Zoe. He then uses his abilities to heal Hal from the burns he suffered as a former Green Lantern. While this saves Hal from his immediate injuries, the revelation raises troubling questions about Noah’s true intentions and sets events in motion that will ultimately cost Hal his life.
Meanwhile, John remains on the alien planet with Sinestro and the Hal-o-gram. Sinestro reveals that Noah visited him in prison, helped him escape, and brought him to the homeworld of the aliens we encountered earlier in the series. Noah also commissioned Sinestro to create a lantern of his own, complete with the yellow coloring associated with Sinestro’s powers. The design is fitting, considering that Sinestro’s philosophy revolves around wielding fear rather than overcoming it.
Photograph by John Johnson/HBO Max
John eventually takes the lantern and returns to Earth, leaving Sinestro behind on the alien planet. With Noah’s motives becoming increasingly suspicious and a new lantern now in play, the consequences of these revelations could be enormous.
Important Conversations
Back on Earth, John returns to his car and begins driving, only to discover that Noah is already inside. The two discuss John killing Noah’s grandmother, Zoe, in 2016. John explains that Zoe ultimately saved his life, but he remembers seeing her before he was burned in the car crash. She could have rescued him sooner, yet she waited until he was in greater danger before stepping in.
Meanwhile, Noah is wrestling with the question of nature versus nurture. He knows Zoe killed the aliens, and he fears that he could eventually follow the same path. Worried that his Manhunter instincts might take control, Noah asks John to kill him after the football game so he never loses himself to that side of his nature.
Photograph by John Johnson/HBO Max
John then meets Sheriff Kane at the football game. They discuss his visit to Hal’s storage unit without her, and John finally reveals that he knows two things: Noah is a Manhunter, and Kane killed Hal. A flashback explains what happened. Hal tried to protect Kane and Noah after learning about Noah freeing Sinestro because it was likely the Guardians would hunt them down. Sheriff Kane felt forced to make the devastating choice to kill the man she loved. It also confirms that the Hal-o-gram was right to suspect her all along.
Kane offers to turn herself in, but John allows her to stay. He explains that Noah asked him to kill him out of fear of what he might become, but John refuses to do it. Rather than condemning Noah because of his heritage, John gives him the chance to choose his own path.
The episode ends on a hopeful note as Kane and her ex-husband, Billy Macon, watch their son lead his team on a game-winning drive. Noah puts on a Nebraska hat, signaling his intention to attend college there. Despite his Manhunter lineage, he appears ready to make his own choices rather than let his ancestry determine his future.
Finding Peace
John heads to the Green Lantern signal in the center of town and calls for Guy Gardner. He reveals that he has a ring and a lantern and intends to take responsibility for protecting Earth, leaving Guy free to patrol the rest of the sector. John also makes one thing clear: he isn’t joining the Green Lantern Corps. He’ll operate on Earth as an independent contractor, and Guy would be wise to respect that arrangement.
Some viewers might find this surprising, considering how readily Guy stood up to Superman in the film Superman. But there’s a difference between challenging someone who will willingly hold back and confronting John, who seems more than capable of fighting back and kicking Guy’s ass. Guy appears to recognize that difference and decides to leave John to his work.
Photograph by John Johnson/HBO Max
John then returns home for a joyful reunion with his family. He has finally reached a place where he can acknowledge the flaws in his upbringing without rejecting the people who raised him. Rather than continuing to distance himself from his family, he can accept his past as part of who he is.
Photograph by John Johnson/HBO Max
Before the Hal-o-gram disappears forever, John shares one final conversation with his former mentor. Hal finally manages to tell John that he loves him, albeit in his own indirect way, before encouraging him to make the job his own. It’s a touching conclusion to a relationship that began with tension and mutual distrust but grew into something much deeper. John then recites a slightly altered version of the Lantern oath, bringing the Hal-o-gram’s existence to an end.
John has officially taken up the mantle of a Lantern, but whether he can truly be called a Green Lantern is another question. By choosing his own path rather than simply following the Corps’ rules, he may be defining a new kind of hero altogether.
Final Thoughts
In brightest day, in darkest night
I’ll embrace my fear, I’ll do what’s right
I choose this ring, I choose this fight
In service to this Lantern’s light
That’s the new oath John recites when he becomes a Lantern, and it perfectly captures what this series has been trying to accomplish: reimagining the Green Lantern mythology on its own terms.
Lanterns and its finale have received a hefty amount of criticism, and I can understand why. Anyone hoping for a faithful adaptation of the Green Lantern comics might understandably feel disappointed. We get very few constructs, the story never expands into a grand galactic adventure, John never wears the traditional suit, and he doesn't recite the familiar oath. In fact, we hear the original oath only twice: first, when an alien uses it to mock Hal in the premiere, and later, when Hal quickly recites it to recharge his ring in the second episode.
But as a grounded detective story about a Lantern investigating a mystery on Earth, the series succeeds. The investigations spanning 2016 and 2026 tell compelling stories, and both Hal and John demonstrate that they're talented detectives. More importantly, the series explores what fearlessness really means. Hal's apparent fearlessness comes from being broken, not from being emotionally invulnerable. It's a compelling allegory that gives his character a depth we might not have gotten from a more conventional superhero adventure.
So, does the finale deliver?
If you're looking for an action-heavy spectacle like many Marvel television finales or previous DC shows, probably not. This finale prioritizes character development and dialogue over elaborate fights and superhero spectacle. And if you wanted a faithful adaptation of a Green Lantern comic, it probably won't satisfy you either.
However, Lanterns set out to be its own kind of story, and it largely succeeds. Unlike the Peacemaker Season 2 finale, which sometimes felt as though it was meandering before suddenly rushing through enough material for an entire third season, Lanterns brings its central mysteries to a satisfying conclusion. It answers the questions it raised, delivers meaningful character resolutions, and gives John the opportunity to define what being a Lantern means to him.
For a finale built around those goals, it knocks it out of the park.
Check out Lanterns streaming on HBO Max.
Episode and Series Ranking:
Article Written By: Jeremy Brown for Stelmach Brown Media 2026
Add comment
Comments